11.18.2026

Are State Medical Boards Doing Enough to Protect Patients?

New Public Citizen report finds declining physician discipline nationwide, raising concerns about medical board accountability and patient safety.

State medical boards are responsible for protecting the public by identifying and disciplining physicians whose misconduct or substandard care puts patients at risk. But a new report from Public Citizen raises serious questions about whether they are adequately fulfilling that responsibility.

The November 2026 report, Ranking of the Rate of State Medical Boards’ Serious Disciplinary Actions, 2023–2025, finds that serious disciplinary actions against physicians have declined nationally, with significant differences in enforcement from state to state.

Andrew C. Meyer, Jr.
These findings echo concerns raised for years by Attorney Andrew C. Meyer, Jr., who has repeatedly called attention to inadequate physician oversight in Massachusetts. 

“This report underscores concerns we have been raising for some time here in Massachusetts. Patients need to know that when a physician’s conduct puts them at risk, the medical board will step in before another patient is harmed. That means investigating complaints promptly, taking decisive action when the facts warrant it, and making it easy for patients to find and understand disciplinary decisions. When a physician’s professional interests conflict with patient safety, patient safety has to come first.”

Report Finds Declining Physician Discipline


Massachusetts is not alone in its concerns over physician discipline. Public Citizen's analysis of all 50 states and the District of Columbia found that the average annual number of serious disciplinary actions against physicians declined approximately 4.1% compared with the 2019–2021 period. More significantly, the rate of serious disciplinary actions per 1,000 physician licenses fell by 14.2%.

Serious disciplinary actions include license revocations, suspensions, restrictions, and certain voluntary license surrenders or limitations while under investigation.

Massachusetts Ranks 37th in Physician Discipline


Massachusetts, despite its reputation for medical excellence, ranked just 37th among 51 jurisdictions in the report.

The state recorded an average of only 0.55 serious disciplinary actions per 1,000 physician licenses annually between 2023 and 2025. According to Public Citizen, Massachusetts would need to increase its annual number of disciplinary actions by approximately 222% to match Alaska's rate, the highest in the country.

Andrew Meyer Outspoken on Medical Board Oversight


The concerns raised in the Public Citizen report are not new to Meyer. In 2019, he was featured in a Boston magazine investigation, "The Secret Truth About Boston Doctors," which examined allegations that physicians with histories of problematic medical care continued practicing without meaningful accountability.

Following publication, Meyer appeared on NECN/NBC10 Boston with journalist Sue O'Connell to discuss shortcomings in Massachusetts physician oversight.

During the interview, Meyer described how difficult it can be for patients to learn about a physician's professional history.

"There’s very little in Massachusetts you can do to protect yourself, other than get a very good recommendation," Meyer said. "In Massachusetts you can find out more about your refrigerator or your toaster than you can about your doctor."

Meyer also described a troubling pattern his firm encounters in medical malpractice cases: seeing the same physicians and hospitals repeatedly involved in cases involving similar problems, without meaningful corrective action.

"We see the same names on a regular basis. We see the same hospitals show up time and time again with the same problems, and one of the major issues is there's no corrective action being taken," he told O'Connell.

Meyer has also questioned whether medical boards composed largely of physicians can adequately protect patients when professional interests may conflict with public safety.

"The Board of Registration is a licensing authority, and it should really be run more by consumers who understand what bad medicine is about rather than doctors," he said.

Recommended Reforms

Meyer supports Public Citizen's recommendations to strengthen medical board accountability, including:
  • Increasing independent public representation on medical boards to reduce potential conflicts of interest.
  • Ensuring adequate funding and staffing to investigate complaints and discipline physicians when warranted.
  • Requiring routine checks of the National Practitioner Data Bank to identify concerning physician histories.
  • Giving boards greater independence from professional medical societies.
  • Improving public access to physician disciplinary and professional history information.

Said Meyer, "Ultimately, medical boards have a duty to protect patients, not shield physicians from scrutiny."

Read the Public Citizen report: Ranking of the Rate of State Medical Boards’ Serious Disciplinary Actions, 2023–2025.

Read the full Boston magazine article, The Secret Truth About Boston Doctors.

Watch Andrew C. Meyer, Jr.'s NECN / NBC 10 Boston interview: When Patients Are Victims of Medical Mistakes.

Lubin & Meyer represents individuals and families in Massachusetts, New Hampshire and Rhode Island.



View our main website at LubinandMeyer.com 

Lubin & Meyer PC - New England's Leader in Medical Malpractice and Personal Injury Law